DEI Litigation Whiplash: Appellate Court Allows the Government to Move Forward with Challenged DEI-Related Executive Orders

Brooke T. Iley and Dominique L. Casimir ●

Uncertainty for companies when making business decisions is a new norm. Tariffs aren’t going to be the only thing that is on again and off again. The same is happening with directives governing diversity, equity, and inclusion (“DEI”) initiatives. In the first two days of President Trump’s second term, he signed two DEI-related executive orders (“EOs”), EO 14151 (Ending Radical And Wasteful Government DEI Programs And Preferencing) and EO 14173 (Ending Illegal Discrimination And Restoring Merit-Based Opportunity). While they were in effect, these EOs caused widespread concern throughout the public and private sector as entities scrambled to understand the implications for their businesses. Approximately a month later, a federal judge in Maryland issued a preliminary injunction that stopped the government from implementing key provisions of the two EOs. However, the tide turned on Friday, March 14, 2025, when a three-judge panel from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit granted the government’s motion to stay the injunction pending appeal. This ruling empowers the government to resume the implementation of EO 14151 and EO 14173.

While the preliminary injunction was in effect, the government was precluded from (1) terminating “equity-related” contracts and grants pursuant to EO 14151, (2) requiring that government contractors and grantees sign a DEI certification pursuant to EO 14173, and (3) bringing any False Claims Act (“FCA”) or other enforcement action premised on the DEI certification. (As we have previously explained, the certification requirement in EO 14173 is intended to deter contractor and grantee DEI-programs by invoking the specter of FCA liability.)

Now that the injunction is stayed, an emboldened government will likely move swiftly to terminate contracts and grants that it views as being “equity-related” and to require contractors and grantees to execute the DEI certification. We have previously recommended general steps that contractors and grantees can take as they navigate a rapidly changing environment in which the president signs new EOs almost daily. Below, we offer recommendations specific to the government’s renewed ability to implement the previously enjoined provisions of the DEI-related EOs.

Read the full client alert on our website.

Court Temporarily Hits the Brakes on EO 14173 Ending Illegal Discrimination: What Employers Should Know

 Anthony B. Haller, Brooke T. Iley, and Theresa A. Topping ●


Big Picture

On February 21, 2025, a federal judge in the District Court of Maryland granted a temporary injunction blocking portions of President Trump’s Executive Orders “Ending Illegal Discrimination and Restoring Merit Based Opportunity” (“14173”) and “Ending Radical and Wasteful Government DEI Programs” (“14151”) (collectively the “EOs”). To learn more about each EO’s directives read Blank Rome’s previous coverage on 14173 here and 14151 here. This is a temporary nationwide ban on certain portions of the EOs.

After pointing out that the Trump Administration has declared “DEI to be henceforth illegal”, the Court found the EOs do not “define any of the operative terms” such as “illegal DEI”, “equity-related”, “promoting DEI”, or “illegal discrimination or preferences”. This vagueness fails to provide companies and organizations with proper notice as to what types of programs are prohibited. Further, the Court found that the EOs likely violate the First Amendment by expressly threatening “the expression of views supportive of equity, diversity and inclusion.” This is a nationwide ban.

Continue reading “Court Temporarily Hits the Brakes on EO 14173 Ending Illegal Discrimination: What Employers Should Know”

Massachusetts Pay Transparency Law: FAQs & February Deadline

Carmen F. Francella III ●

 The Commonwealth of Massachusetts Executive Office of Labor and Workforce Development recently published FAQs that provide guidance on the Commonwealth’s new Salary Range Transparency Act (“the Act”). The Act requires employers with 100 or more employees at any time during the prior calendar year to submit their Equal Employment Opportunity (“EEO”)-1 reports to the Commonwealth by February 1 of each year. The FAQs include information for employers on their reporting requirements under the Act. Individual data will not be made public; only aggregated data will be published.

Key Takeaways and Clarifications from the FAQs:

  • Employers need not create new reports or make changes to their existing EEO-1 report. Employers may “file the same copy of the EEO report you filed with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (“EEOC”).” Employers have the option, however, to customize a report reflecting the required data for only Massachusetts-based employees.
  • Employers are not required to submit W-2 income earnings data by race/ethnicity, sex, and job category to the Commonwealth, since pay data is not part of the current EEOC reporting requirements.
  • The initial EEO-1 report is due by February 1, 2025, and annually on the same date thereafter. Since February 1 falls on a Saturday this year, reports will be accepted until Monday, February 3, 2025. The other EEO reports are due by the same deadline but on a biennial basis: EEO-3 and EEO-5 this year (2025), and EEO-4 next year (2026).
  • Employers must submit the report in PDF, JPG, or PNG format to the Secretary of State’s office through the web portal. The web portal for filing the EEO-1 reports is live, and can be accessed here. 

In addition to the February deadline for wage data reporting, the Act also requires Massachusetts employers to disclose salary ranges for most employment postings by October 29, 2025. We expect the Commonwealth to release additional guidance for employers on the pay disclosure requirements. In the meantime, more general information on the upcoming requirements can be found in our recent Workplace blog post: Massachusetts Governor Signs Pay Transparency Law – Blank Rome Workplace.

Employers Are Extra Grateful This Thanksgiving After Federal Court Sets Aside DOL’s Salary Threshold Increase

Theresa A. Topping ●

Salary threshold. . .$35,568.00. . .the Eastern District of Texas. . .not the classic answers you expect to hear from your loved ones around the Thanksgiving table when you ask, “Hey guys, what are you most thankful for?” While family, friends, food, and a roof over your head are all great, the fact that the United States District Court for the Eastern District of Texas shot down the Department of Labor’s (“DOL”) attempt at increasing the overtime salary threshold to $58,656.00 is right up there for employers.

The DOL’s Not-So-Final “Final Rule”

Back on April 23, 2024, the DOL announced their “final rule,” which entailed a multi-phase increase of the “white-collar exemption” (the executive, administrative, and professional employees (“EAP”)) salary threshold from $35,568.00 to $43,888.00, starting on July 1, 2024, and then up to $58,656.00, starting on January 1, 2025 (with increases automatically occurring every three years thereafter). Notably absent were any changes to the DOL’s “duties” test, which must be analyzed in conjunction with a salary when determining whether an EAP employee is exempt from overtime. At the time of its announcement, the DOL projected their final rule would make four million workers newly eligible for overtime payments and cost employers nationwide roughly $1.4 billion in the first year alone. Being thankful for a $35,568.00 threshold is looking more and more understandable now, isn’t it?

Continue reading “Employers Are Extra Grateful This Thanksgiving After Federal Court Sets Aside DOL’s Salary Threshold Increase”

Massachusetts Governor Signs Pay Transparency Law

Carmen F. Francella III ●

Massachusetts now joins a growing list of states and other localities with pay transparency laws.

On July 31, 2024, Massachusetts Governor Maura Healey signed into law Bill H.4890. The Bill contains new pay transparency and wage reporting requirements applicable to certain employers with employees in Massachusetts. The law requires employers with 25 or more employees in the Commonwealth to disclose salary range information on job postings, and to provide pay range information to current employees in certain circumstances.

Continue reading “Massachusetts Governor Signs Pay Transparency Law”

California’s New Workplace Violence Prevention Law: July 1, 2024, Compliance Deadline—Are You Ready?

Caroline Powell Donelan ●

The effective date of California’s Senate Bill 553 is fast approaching, and the law covers nearly every employer and every employment facility in California with the exception of healthcare facilities and other facilities governed by different legal standards, most remote workers, and businesses with fewer than 10 employees.

Whether you are based in California or operate a worksite in the state with more than 10 employees, compliance is mandatory. The requirements, set forth in SB 553, are detailed and complex, establishing rules for planning, logging, and record-keeping, as well as worker training, which will all be overseen and enforced by the California Occupational Safety and Health Act (“Cal/OSHA”).

Specifically, California employers must meet four broad categories of obligations that go into effect July 1, 2024, including:

  1. The creation of a workplace violence prevention plan.
  2. The creation of a workplace violence incident log.
  3. Training requirements.
  4. Recordkeeping requirements.
Continue reading “California’s New Workplace Violence Prevention Law: July 1, 2024, Compliance Deadline—Are You Ready?”

Finally!? DOL Cranks Up Exempt Salary Threshold Near $60,000

Jason E. Reisman ●

We’ve all known this day was coming—it was just a matter of time. From the moment the Biden Department of Labor (“DOL”) announced that the Trump DOL’s 2020 increase to the Fair Labor Standards Act salary threshold for the so-called “white collar” exemptions (primarily the executive, administrative, and professional exemptions (“EAP”)) was not good enough, it became crystal clear that a new rule was in the works.

Although it took the DOL some time to put its thoughts together, it issued the proposed new rule in September 2023, and awaited public comments—33,000 of those followed. After reviewing each of the comments, the DOL announced its final rule yesterday. Here are the basics:

  • It will be effective as of July 1, 2024.
  • There are no changes to the duties tests (perhaps the only positive news).
  • The new salary thresholds for the EAP exemptions and the highly compensated employee (“HCE”) exemption essentially will be phased in beginning on July 1, 2024, and then fully implemented on January 1, 2025.
    • Note: On July 1, 2024, the DOL is implementing an interim increase to the thresholds (as noted below) that is based on current earnings data using the methodology established in the Trump DOL’s final rule.
    • Then, on January 1, 2025, the DOL will use the new methodology to establish the full salary thresholds.
  • Beginning on July 1, 2027, and every three years thereafter, the DOL will update the salary thresholds to align with the then-current earnings data.
  • Here’s a chart based on the DOL’s FAQ that provides the relevant data points:
DATESTANDARD SALARY LEVELHCE ANNUAL COMPENSATION THRESHOLD
Before 7/1/2024$684/wk ($35,568/yr)$107,432
7/1/2024$844/wk ($43,888/yr)$132,964
1/1/2025$1,128/wk ($58,656/yr)$151,164
1/1/2027 (and every three years thereafter)TBD based on 35th percentile of full-time salaried earnings in lowest Census regionTBD based on 85th percentile of full-time salaried employees nationally

Where’s the good news for employers, you ask? Uh, there really isn’t any … except maybe that the new salary threshold is not immediately rising to $60,000 and the expectation that any one of a number of business organizations is likely to challenge the new rule, perhaps using a number of the theories raised in the fighting that ultimately resulted in the rule being blocked by Judge Mazzant in the federal court in the Eastern District of Texas.

If the above did not wake you up, please keep in mind that the DOL has projected that costs for employers in the first year of this new rule will be about $1.4 billion and the rule will make four million workers newly eligible for overtime pay (unless their employer intervenes in some fashion).

So, what do you do? Grab your popcorn and watch the challenges to the new rule roll in? Maybe—but you should start considering those currently exempt employees who fall in the “danger zone” between $35,568 annually and $43,888 annually and evaluate whether you can consider a raise to the new threshold or instead need to potentially reclassify them to non-exempt status. Fortunately, that danger zone (leading up to July 1, 2024) is somewhat narrow when compared to what will come on January 1, 2025. At least the phased implementation provides a longer window to watch the anticipated legal challenges unfold. As an added note of caution, you should remember that current state law minimum salary thresholds like those that exist in New York and California, which are significantly higher than those in the DOL rule, continue to apply. Don’t touch that dial!

Keeping Up: Guidance on California’s New Pay Data Reporting for Employers

Natalie Alameddine ●

As most employers with employees working in California or assigned to a California location know, and as we reported in “Big Brother Just Got Bigger: Expanded Pay Data Reporting Expected to Hit the Golden State,” 2022 legislation obligated employers with 100 or more workers to report pay data via separate pay data reports to the agency now known as the California Civil Rights Department (“CRD”). Continuing that trend, in 2023 California statutes enhanced the existing pay equity rules by requiring employers to post salary ranges in job postings, and to provide the same information to their employees upon request.

With the May 8, 2024, deadline for employers to submit their 2023 pay reports quickly approaching, it is important to be aware of the recent changes to the reporting requirements implemented by the CRD. Employers should begin to collect data now and keep these key changes in mind:

  • Employers must now submit information about the number of employees per each employee group who worked remotely. The CRD FAQs define a “remote worker” as “a payroll or labor contractor employee who is entirely remote, teleworking, or home-based, and has no expectation to regularly report in person to a physical establishment to perform work duties.” Hybrid workers who appear in person for any portion of time would not be considered remote workers for pay data reporting purposes.
Continue reading “Keeping Up: Guidance on California’s New Pay Data Reporting for Employers”

2024 Brings Change for New York Employers

Mara B. Levin and Anthony A. Mingione


LEGISLATION

This year brings significant legislative updates recently passed in New York that may impact your business operations. Three of these laws, and a recent Court of Appeals decision, introduce important changes that require attention and potential adjustment of your employment practices.

Worker’s Bill of Rights

Effective July 1, 2024, New York City employers must post and distribute a “Worker’s Bill of Rights” notice, informing employees of their rights under federal, state, and local workplace laws—regardless of immigration status. Some of these rights include: Paid Safe and Sick Leave, Minimum Wage, Temporary Schedule Changes, Fast Food Worker Rights, and right to organize.

Employers must provide this notice in English and any other language that is spoken as a primary language by at least five percent of their employees. Failing to meet notice and posting requirements could subject employers to a civil penalty of up to $500.

Read the full client alert on our website.

Employers Get a 2-Year Breather on Complying with the Secure 2.0 Change to Catch-Up Contributions

Daniel L. Morgan ●

The Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) issued Notice 2023-62 last week, which addresses a change made by the SECURE 2.0 Act of 2022 (“Secure 2.0”) to the 401(k) plan rules applicable to so-called “catch-up contributions” that may be made by older plan participants.

Background—Catch-Up Contributions and Roth Contributions

Employers are permitted to write their 401(k) plans to allow employees who are age 50 or older to make catch-up contributions in excess of the annual limit on elective contributions. Therefore, for example, someone who is at least 50 years old in 2023 can elect this year to contribute an additional $7,500 on top of the normal limit of $22,500 that a person who is younger than 50 can elect to contribute.

Employers are also permitted to allow 401(k) plan participants to make their elective contributions as Roth contributions, which go into the plan on an after-tax basis. If these Roth contributions satisfy requirements on how long they must be held in the plan, they ultimately can be distributed, along with earnings on the contributions, tax free.

Continue reading “Employers Get a 2-Year Breather on Complying with the Secure 2.0 Change to Catch-Up Contributions”
Exit mobile version
%%footer%%